Raymond Hubbard was one blind referee of Reisinger's (1997) paper, "The impact of research designs on R2 in linear regression models: an exploratory meta-analysis". In his commentary, Hubbard (1997) reports about several issues in connection with the review process of this paper. Therefore, I think it is necessary to give several insights in the review process from my point of view as the author.
Reisinger, H (1997), "Rejoinder to “Construct validity and other issues pertaining to ‘The impact of research designs on R2 in linear regression models: an exploratory meta-analysis'”", Journal of Empirical Generalisations in Marketing Science, Vol. 2, No. 3